(This continues our discussion of story structure from Part 1)
Sources of Structure
As we’ve said, there’s a lot of confusion as to what screenplay (and thus, story) structure really is. Just after sound established itself in films, in the 1930s, screenwriting was taken up by imported writers: playwrights, novelists, and news journalists. The playwrights brought with them a concept derived from the theater: act structure. Commonly, many full-length, modern plays contained three acts. These, in turn, were derived from Aristotle’s, The Poetics,
wherein he elucidated what made for a successful story. Essentially, he broke stories into three parts: beginning, middle, and end, and described what made them each separate and distinct. He stated:
“A whole is that which has a beginning, a middle, and a conclusion. A beginning is that which itself does not of necessity follow something else, but after which there naturally is, or comes into being, something else. A conclusion, conversely, is that which itself naturally follows something else, either of necessity or for the most part, but has nothing else after it. A middle is that which itself naturally follows something else, and has something else after it. Well-constructed plots should neither begin from a random point nor conclude at a random point, but should use the elements we have mentioned (i.e., beginning, middle, and conclusion).” ---The Poetics, Aristotle, Translation by Richard Janko, Hackett Publishing Co., Indianapolis/Cambridge, 1987, p.10.
While this seems both obvious and pedantic, it implies certain things which I will show fail to account for modern narrative unless one takes a different view than the leading and accepted structural models offered today. First, his use of the word, “whole” implies that a story must be seen as a unified thing, an interdependent organic corpus, rather than a mere collection of linked, or even related, parts. The parts require reason for their being linked, i.e., structural support. But while Aristotle’s ideas are a starting point for structure, they have been superseded by the advancement of narrative. His notion of “The Three Unities,” (time, place, and action) have long ago been abandoned. Stories extend over unlimited stretches of time and many, many locations. Perhaps only action continues to adhere by compelling story events to relate to one unifying plot. But, today, even that is up for debate.
Next, as used, the term, “naturally,” in relation to following and preceding the three parts, implies causality of some kind, not necessarily limited to causal events in linear time. I submit that it can include causality of meaning even when causality of linear time is lacking. The last sentence supports this notion of causal meaning rather than just causal time, because, for example, any time preceding a meaningful one could apply if time was the only requirement. But, if meaning is a requirement, then, and only then, a random beginning is excluded, precisely what is called for by Aristotle.
By the thirties, screenplay structure was described, for example, as “boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy gets girl back.” Writers like Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur used to say, “first, you get your character (i.e., the protagonist) up a tree, then you throw rocks at him (i.e., challenge him with difficulties), then you get him down (i.e. resolve it all).” So, classic Aristotelian structure, as adopted by classic Hollywood films, was a story, unified by a protagonist, with a causality of meaning and time. However, as narrative film evolved, the causality of time became malleable and even optional in certain cases.
In the late 1970s, Syd Field, a reader and story analyst for an independent film producer, applied these ideas to modern screenwriting in his first book, Screenplay, Dell, 1st Ed., 1979, wherein he described a “paradigmatic” approach, refining the three-part, or, as it had become known since the 1930s, the “three-act structure.” He stated that the parts broke down into a paradigm, a model, with a consistent pattern of about 25% - 50% - 25%, proportionally, for each part (or “act”) in succession. And though he never said it, it had an obvious correspondence to Aristotle’s “beginning, middle, and end”. This was based on Field’s analysis of several thousand screenplays. Field’s general definition of “screenplay structure” is:
“A linear progression of related incidents, episodes, and events leading to a dramatic resolution.” – Screenplay, MJF Books, 3rd Ed., pp. 14-15.
Field described items he called “plot points,” the primary ones (I and II, though there can be many other “secondary” ones) of which always preceded a transition from act to act. His paradigm consisted of Act 1 (the set-up), running about a quarter of the story, Act 2 (the confrontation), running about half the story, and Act 3 (the resolution), running the last quarter of the story. Each act transition was preceded and precipitated by events (plot points) which happened to (or because of action by) the protagonist, thereby generating an urgency for resolution. The first transition (Act 1/Act 2) is the moment when the hero formally sets out to resolve the dilemma he has had thrust upon him. The second transition (Act 2/Act 3) is the moment when complications have reached their nadir for the hero, and decisive action is begun in order to force a successful resolution.
This structural notion has its supporters and its detractors (II-1), but there is no denying that it holds sway in a great many films. Consider these exchanges, however, from [David] Lynch on Lynch, Edited by Chris Rodley, p. 62:
Rodley – “Is that [Lynch’s preference for European films] something to do with the fact that they’re not so driven by narrative as American films?”
Lynch – “Yes. Exactly. I think so”
And from [Terry] Gilliam on Gilliam, Edited by Ian Christie, Faber and Faber, 1999, p. 255:
Christie – “You think today’s audience is corrupted by simple storylines, structured in three acts with strong motivation, just like the screenwriting manuals teach?
Gilliam – “Exactly.”
Christie – “Whereas your natural instinct is to construct a Chinese box of as much complexity as you can get away with...”
Gilliam – “I no longer know who does and doesn’t like my work. I’m confused. I know almost everybody who loves movies loves (FEAR AND LOATHING IN LAS VEGAS). I know people on the technical side and musicians love it, and people from a generation that isn’t in denial love it, and there are these fourteen year old kids from high school who love it. I’m trying to corrupt youth in my own way, not in Spielberg’s: mine is a Socratic corruption. It’s interesting to see kids write on the Web, ‘This is the best movie I’ve ever seen.’”
His, “mine is a Socratic corruption” is worthy of note. By one definition, the Socratic Method is (my truncation):
“—a form of philosophical inquiry in which the questioner explores the implications of others’ positions, to stimulate rational thinking and illuminate ideas. It is a dialectical method that often involves an oppositional discussion in which the defense of one point of view is pitted against another; one participant may lead another to contradict himself in some way, strengthening the inquirer’s own point.”--- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socratic_method
And:
“The term Socratic Questioning is used to describe a kind of questioning in which an original question is responded to as though it were an answer. This, in turn, forces the first questioner to reformulate a new question in light of the progress of the discourse.”
Gilliam, and artists like him, above all, are trying to provoke thought, to confront questions, and, through the process, yield new and better answers. One will find, however, that what I will be calling, “the deep structure” in such stories, is still classically present, and, in fact, remains unscathed.
Over time, various writers introduced concepts such as the “inciting incident,” the “strange attractor,” the “two goals with a reversal,” various increases in the number of acts, and “whammos,” or sequences of scenes which comprised a three act-like sub-unit (or sub-structure) within acts, a sequence of scenes built around an escalation (i.e., a transformation) of tension or comedy. STAR WARS and RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK, for example, were classic “whammo” pictures, as were the serials of the 1930s and 1940s like FLASH GORDON and BUCK ROGERS (II-2).
In his second book, Field identified something he called the “Mid-Point,” (The Screenwriter’s Workbook, p. 128),
which fell approximately at the center of the story, and broke the middle and longest act into two roughly equal parts. This was supposed to signal an overall elevation of the stakes and a corresponding heightening of the tension, something that Field, himself, had earlier identified as functioning incrementally throughout the entire second act. The Mid-Point, has been described by some as delivering a powerful escalation to the engine driving the story. When used well, it impacts the story profoundly. It threatens or amplifies the success or failure of the primary need compelling the protagonist. Some have even said that if it has a negative effect, the ultimate resolution often will be positive, and if it has a positive effect, the resolution will be negative. This may be true most commonly with big box-office films, high concept stories of the blockbuster variety. I don’t know how fundamental the need for an operative mid-point is, but I suspect it only helps stories to better increase their dramatic forward momentum. However…
I submit that this mid-point, as an identifiable moment at the heart of the story, is common, but not necessarily always found in successful or produced screenplays. Its identification, along with Field’s concept of what he calls, “Pinch I” and “Pinch II” coming, in turn, around the middle of each half of act two (pages 45 and 75 of his 120 page idealized model) (II-3), seems to be Field’s response to the difficulty he was encountering in his work with writers who were using his paradigm and becoming stalled in getting through their own second acts. He needed to find a way to break the second act into more manageable parts, as were the first and third, so he may have looked for and “found” (as a product of his perceived “need”) a possibility in this “here today, gone tomorrow” (at least for some films) notion of the mid-point. The elegance of finding films breaking down into equal quarters must have seemed irresistible to someone for whom mathematics suddenly describing art implied a formula for successful screenwriting.
Structure from Character
However, one insight Field had in formulating his paradigmatic approach to Aristotle’s three parts, the element tying the structural components together, was mentioned in the first edition of his first book and, since then, has been almost forgotten (likely, even by Field, himself—he refers to it in print not at all since first identifying it). It was never, as it should have been, sufficiently stressed in his books, and it was almost universally missed by his students and members of the academic community, many of whom initially took up Field’s paradigm with great enthusiasm, only to later reject it as too formulaic and restrictive (II-4).
But the insight Field had that has never been given its due was the profound observation that (his “notion” of):
The Plot Point is a function of the main character (i.e., the protagonist)
Because Plot Point I and Plot Point II are fundamental structural components of his paradigm signaling the transition to the succeeding acts, this, then, means that:
A story’s structure, itself, is dependent upon, and a function of, the protagonist (II-5).
When one examines the key implication of this (an implication that seems to have gone un-recognized even by its source (II–6), one realizes that the idea requires that:
She/he/it must transform (or not, despite the implicit and apparent-to-its audience need for it) as the result of contending with the story’s dilemma.
While this may sound like so much rhetoric of our own, it gets at the heart of structure like nothing before or since has managed. And Field’s implied liberal definition of the protagonist (Screenplay, 3rd Ed., pp. 123-4) as any one of several possibilities including a person, couple, group, city, country, species, idea, or even a metaphor (also mostly ignored by his readers), paved the way for a structural model far more powerful than the one (3-act structure) that has become identified with him. Field, while recognizing the possibility of the protagonist transforming, sees it as incidental, dependent on the particular story, and just as easily not present in serviceable stories (II-7). While this last point may be true, Field misses the notion that the vacuum created by such an absence is filled within the mind of the audience.
The importance and value to storytelling of our notion of the growing or changing hero is that the unity it supplies to stories is actually of concrete and profound use to its audience. It is of far more use, in fact, than the earlier unifying element according to the structure-as-function-of-plot advocates, i.e., subject.
Thus:
Unity supplied by the structural presence of three parts about a common subject provides information, i.e., data, essentially resolving the mystery of the ending of the story.
On the other hand:
Unity supplied by the structural presence of three parts about a common and growing hero provides resonant illumination, essentially insight into both the story’s resolution, and potential insight into the individual audience-member’s own human experience.
“Resonant,” because the audience is now experiencing the events in the story in common with the protagonist, and, “illumination,” because new truths are emerging. In this second example, the potential exists, based on the quality of the story and its execution, not just for the story hero’s growth, but for the audience’s growth. #
(Stay tuned for Part 3)
Please Re-stack if you found this article of interest.
_____
II-1 - In Screenwriters’ Masterclass, p. 133, screenwriter and director, Darren Aronofsky said, “I was aware enough to know those Syd Field books were evil. I was always anti-establishment enough to resist those. And I sort of developed a process which is the first job of trying to identify a three-act structure, which I do believe in (italics, mine). I’d love to see if there’s anything beyond the three-act structure but I think it works very well as a narrative structure of a film.”
So, in the name of being “anti-establishment” he falls into the—can it be described any other way?—reactionary, though radically-chic response to Field that developed over time. He remains uninformed (self-protection, perhaps?), and yet he prefers and uses Field’s own structural approach while longing for something “beyond the three-act structure.” I’ll show that it’s all around him and he just refuses to see it.
II-2 – In Patrick McGilligan’s Backstory 1, p. 287, screenwriter Richard Maibaum (numerous early James Bond films, CHITTY, CHITTY, BANG, BANG), said, “You know, Hitchcock once told me, ‘If I have thirteen bumps in a picture, I think I’ve got a picture.’ A bump is something like someone says, ‘I’m looking for a man who has a short index finger,’ and a totally unexpected guy says, ‘You mean like this?’ (i.e., one of Syd Field’s secondary Plot Points). That’s in THE 39 STEPS. After DR. NO (producers) Cubby (Broccoli), Harry (Saltzman), and myself decided that we weren’t going to be satisfied with thirteen bumps in a Bond story, we wanted thirty-nine.”
II-3 – These were moments or scenes in the narrative Syd Field identified as re-connecting the narrative to the story’s through-line, in effect “pinching” it to the spine to hold the story on-track toward resolution, rather than wandering off in any direction the writer might have otherwise chosen. - The Screenwriter’s Workbook, pp. 153-8. However, by Field’s book, Four Screenplays, Dell, 1994, he seems to have abandoned the notion of the Pinch.
II-4 - They rightly complained about writing screenplays by the numbers: putting Plot point I on page 25, the Act 1/Act 2 Transition on page 30, Pinch I on page 45, the Mid-point on page 60, Pinch II on page 75, Plot point II on page 85, and the Act 2/Act 3 Transition on page 90, etc. Of course, to be fair, even a superficial reading of Syd Field cannot help but show that Field never urged such a hard-line, fixed and unyielding page-numbering approach. He used them only as rules-of-thumb. And, in fact, the page numbers mattered much less than the minutes to which they corresponded in the film. His point related to the writer developing the story dilemma quickly, and moving the narrative on by certain points in time during the movie. Of course, these same students and academics complain incessantly when a movie runs on too long or doesn’t develop its characters sufficiently. Field found that well-developed and paced screenplays usually accomplished this in a 25%-50%-25% breakdown of the three acts, give or take a few minutes. What his former disciples cannot complain about is the relative accuracy of that assessment. Check classic films, modern films, or favorite films for yourself. Syd Field’s insight is, for the most part, borne out.
II-5 – Field’s original idea is found in the 3rd Edition of his first book on screenwriting, Screenplay, first on p. 13, and again on p. 123. The inference that structure is a function of the protagonist is my own. If the protagonist refuses either to take on or to resolve the dilemma, there is no story; hence, there is no structure (because, as a story, there is no meaning).
II-6 – In a review of Field’s books since first encountering this initial insight of the “plot point” as “a function of the main character” in the 1st Edition of his first book, I have found no evidence that Field even understands the implication of his observation. In other words, it may just have been “how-to book” rhetoric. This seems clear when one recognizes that he stays entirely on the surface level in his discussions of structure. In fact, in The Screenwriter’s Workbook, he even re-defines his notion of structure: “But when I thought about it, I realized structure is a function of story.” p. 139. (WHOA! Ya think? That is the most self-evident observation I’ve ever seen in a book on writing.) Well, to be fair, from his use of the word throughout, it is clear that he means “story” up on the surface or plot level, just like almost every other screenwriting “guru,” not, as we see it, having a multi-level structure. (italics, mine)
II-7 – The Screenwriter’s Workbook, p.58
(Stay tuned for Part 3)




